Abercrombie vs Levi's Jeans: Worth the Price?

In the ever-evolving world of denim, two brands consistently dominate the conversation: Abercrombie & Fitch, with its viral TikTok-famous fits, and Levi's, the 150-year-old denim authority. But which brand truly delivers the best value for your money in 2026? We've conducted an exhaustive comparison covering fit, quality, price, sizing, style range, sustainability, and durability to help you make an informed decision.

The Heritage Factor: Levi's vs. The New Guard

Levi's invented the blue jean in 1873, creating an American icon that has dressed everyone from miners to models. According to InStyle's comprehensive denim testing, Levi's remains a top choice among fashion editors, with styles like the Wedgie Bootcut and classic 501s earning praise for their "stretchy denim and perfect high-rise fit."

Abercrombie & Fitch, meanwhile, has undergone a remarkable transformation from preppy mall brand to inclusive denim powerhouse. Their Curve Love collection, specifically designed with 10 different body types in mind, has become a social media sensation, with fashion influencers praising its gap-free waistband technology.

Fit & Sizing: Where Each Brand Excels

Abercrombie's Modern Approach

Abercrombie's standout feature is its size inclusivity. The brand offers sizes 23-37 (00-20W) with multiple inseam options. InStyle testers particularly loved the Curve Love Ultra High Rise 90s Straight Jean, noting these jeans "fit snugly to your natural curves but maintain enough stretch for easy movement" and importantly, "goodbye gaping."

The Curve Love technology uses contoured waistbands designed to eliminate the dreaded gap at the back, a common complaint with traditional straight-sized jeans. Fashion blogger Marina Torres, quoted in InStyle's testing, emphasizes that "it's important for me to have a wide size range that caters to various body types," making Abercrombie a standout choice for inclusivity.

Levi's Classic Cuts

Levi's offers extensive sizing across multiple fits, with their most popular women's styles including the Ribcage, 501 Original, Wedgie, and 312 Shaping Slim. Vogue's denim guide highlights the 501 Skinny Jeans as an editor favorite, praising their "laid-back effortlessness" that has "made them a staple for icons from James Dean to Kate Moss."

InStyle writer Isabel Bekele tested the Wedgie Bootcut and concluded: "I would say this product is worth buying because it goes with every outfit and isn't particularly trendy, meaning you can wear it for years to come." Levi's also excels with their 312 Shaping Slim jeans, which come "in inseams that will hit at just the right place (sans wallet-draining tailoring)," according to InStyle.

Quality & Construction: Built to Last?

Celebrity stylist Tracy Shapoff, who works with A-list clients, told InStyle that she relies on "longevity, quality, and an understanding of the body" when selecting jeans. Stylist Rose Lauture adds that premium denim "usually has a rich indigo hue, which comes from natural dyes compared to synthetic dyes often used in lower-quality denim."

Levi's denim is renowned for its durability, with many pairs lasting decades. The brand uses heavyweight denim (typically 11.5-13.5 oz) in their rigid styles, which Lauture notes means "the heavier the denim, the better the chances are that the jeans are made with a strong, durable fabric that will last long."

Abercrombie's recent denim uses a blend of cotton with elastane for stretch, prioritizing comfort and fit over the rigid, heavyweight construction of traditional Levi's. While this means they're immediately comfortable, some fashion experts note that high-stretch denim may not maintain its shape as well over time compared to low-stretch or rigid options.

Price Point Analysis

Abercrombie jeans typically retail between $80-$120, with their popular Curve Love styles priced around $90-$100. Levi's prices vary widely by style: classic 501s run $98-$108, while premium collections can reach $148. Both brands frequently offer sales, making them accessible at various price points.

As InStyle's research notes, the difference between designer and budget jeans often comes down to fabric and construction. Lauture explains: "Designer jeans are often made from 100 percent raw cotton, which gives them a more structured and premium feel... Budget jeans typically include some elastane or polyester, making them less stiff and more stretchy right away."

Style Range: Trend vs. Timeless

Levi's offers unparalleled variety with dozens of fits: skinny, straight, bootcut, flare, wide-leg, and baggy. Their Drop Barrel Jean represents their embrace of contemporary trends, with Vogue noting that barrel jeans are now "a denim wardrobe staple."

Abercrombie focuses on trend-forward fits that resonate with younger consumers: ultra-high-rise straight legs, curve-hugging bootcuts, and relaxed wide-legs. Their 90s Straight silhouette has become particularly popular, aligning with what Vogue describes as the return of "nostalgic" high-waisted, straight-leg styles that "feel downright cool."

Sustainability Comparison

Levi's leads in sustainability initiatives with their Water<Less™ technology, which has saved billions of liters of water in manufacturing. They also offer extensive documentation of their environmental impact and have committed to 100% sustainably-sourced cotton.

Abercrombie has made strides with their "Better Cotton" sourcing and commitment to reducing water usage, though they're less transparent about specific metrics. Both brands participate in textile recycling programs, though Levi's SecondHand resale platform offers a more comprehensive circular economy approach.

Durability: The Long-Term Investment

Fashion blogger Marina Torres, interviewed by InStyle, emphasizes: "It's important that the jeans I buy will last me for years and years, if not for a lifetime. Good jeans have to maintain their shape after wear."

Levi's rigid and low-stretch denim excels in longevity. Stylist Emily Evans told InStyle she "tries to shop for pairs with low Lycra, or stretchy, content, so they maintain their shape."

Abercrombie's stretch denim offers immediate comfort but may require more frequent replacement. However, InStyle tester Jennifer praised similar stretchy jeans for maintaining "fit and shape, no matter how many times I wash it," suggesting that quality stretch denim can also last when properly constructed.

The Verdict: Which Should You Choose?

**Choose Abercrombie if:** You prioritize modern fit technology, need inclusive sizing with curve-friendly designs, want immediate comfort with plenty of stretch, or follow current trends like ultra-high rises and 90s-inspired silhouettes.

**Choose Levi's if:** You want heritage denim that will last decades, prefer rigid or low-stretch construction, need classic styles that transcend trends, or prioritize sustainability and transparent manufacturing practices.

As Vogue's denim guide concludes: "The best jeans for women are the pairs you want to live in—ones you can wear over and over again, that only get better each time you slip them on." Both brands deliver on this promise, just in different ways.

Stylist Rose Lauture's advice rings especially true: "The right pair of denim is the one you feel the most confident and comfortable in, so take your time and enjoy the process."

Expert Shopping Tips

Before purchasing, Lauture recommends: "Grab your measuring tape! You'll want to find three key measurements: waist, hip, and inseam." She also advises testing denim weight and checking stitching quality—"if there are any loose threads, it's an immediate red flag."

Emily Evans adds a crucial tip: "Don't worry about the size on the label. Each brand is cut so differently, it doesn't matter if the size differs from your normal pants." When possible, order multiple sizes to find your perfect fit—many retailers now offer free returns specifically for this purpose.

Style Your Perfect Denim with LOOQS

Found your perfect jeans? The journey doesn't end there. Building complete, cohesive outfits around your denim is an art—and that's where LOOQS comes in. Our AI-powered platform helps you discover exactly what tops, shoes, and accessories work best with your denim style, creating looks that reflect your personal aesthetic while staying current with fashion trends.

Whether you're styling Abercrombie's Curve Love straight-legs with the perfect white tee or pairing Levi's 501s with cowboy boots for that effortless cool-girl vibe, LOOQS transforms your wardrobe decisions from overwhelming to intuitive. Visit looqs.me/promo to discover how personal styling powered by advanced AI can elevate your denim game—because great jeans deserve great styling.